5 Steps to Identify a Good Idea (b)

I added 30,000+ followers on IG in April. The secret wasn’t volume. But creating a process to filter out good ideas to find the great ideas. So we used a process we learned from Paddy Galloway to identify great ideas.

And as always, thank you to our partners Ahrefs and Heatmap.

Get your brand in front of 200,000+ marketers & founders.

In partnership with Ahrefs

Increase Your Search Traffic + Leads with Ahrefs

Building a winning SEO strategy in 2024 is no easy task.

But fortunately for brands, Ahrefs has made it 10x easier to succeed with their suite of easy-to-use tools:

  1. Smart Keyword Suggestions

    • Save hours of manual research identifying untapped keyword opportunities to increase your search traffic (one of my personal favorite tools).

  2. Search Intent

    • Not all traffic is equal.

      Target the right audience by understanding the actual search intent of your ICPs.

  3. Content Grader

    • Every piece of content has room for improvement.

      This tool helps you identify and improve your content to achieve higher rankings on Google.

  4. Learn 192 Languages

    • Reaching new markets quickly has never been easier.

    • Effortlessly expand your international presence with a list of keywords accurately translated into 192 languages.

    • The best part —you can start for free today. Learn more about Ahrefs' AI features and their use cases.

There are 5 hallmarks of a great video idea.

In a recent episode of Sweat Equity, my co-host Brian broke down Paddy Galloway’s 5-step formula for identifying a winning content idea.

For context, Paddy has a YouTube channel with 500K subscribers from just 33 uploads and has helped grow channels like Mr. Beast and RedBull.

And to give you an idea of dedicated idea generation - he typically brainstorms 100 ideas to get to 1 winner.

So here are the 5 key things he looks for.

1: Appeal to Your Core, Casual, and New Audience

Your content ideas need to cater to three audience groups to reach the biggest total addressable market (TAM):

  • Core - These are the die-hard fans who watch every single video.

  • Casual - These viewers tune in sometimes, but maybe only for selected topics. Different casual viewers will watch depending on their specific interests.

  • New - These are the viewers who could be interested in your content but you haven't reached them yet. This is where you use trending topics like Wimbledon to lure them in and introduce them to our channel.

2: Easy to Convey in a Title or Thumbnail

Your content idea should be easy to distill into a clear, compelling title and thumbnail.

These constraints force you to cut to the heart of what makes your video interesting and valuable.

Take our "Good vs. Bad Content" series. The title immediately tells you what the video is about and what to expect.

Ask yourself: Can I convey the key point in a snappy, attention-grabbing title?

The easier it is for potential viewers to understand what your video offers, the more likely they are to watch.

3: Unique & Novelty Value

This is how you stand out in a crowded content feed.

Everyone and their grandma might be talking about Wimbledon, but they're all focusing on the same old angles - the matches, the players, the scores.

But because we approached it from a completely different perspective, dissecting how they promoted the event and engaged fans - we carved out our own niche.

So always ask:

  • What's the angle that no one else is taking?

  • How can I approach this in a way that's fresh, surprising, and uniquely valuable to my audience?

4: Combine 1 or More Viral Formats Together

Your idea should be able to be communicated in at least one viral format for the platform you post on. For us, it’s the talking head format that works so well on IG.

5: Friends Get Excited When You Talk About It

How do your friends react when you share the content idea with them?

For example, when I shared my idea for, “How Wimbledon Gained 1M New Followers in 14 Days” with my COO, Faiez, his reaction told me everything I needed to know.

“Holy shit, that’s f****n crazy.”

That’s how I knew it was a winner.

So pay attention to those emotional cues. More often than not, it's leading you to your next great video.

In partnership with Heatmap

Is Your Brand Still Using Clickmaps?

It’s 2024, and while clicks are nice, revenue is what really matters. 

But when it comes to website optimization, most brands are still making decisions based on where people click.

Here’s why this is a problem:

Click maps are misleading. 

They don’t show revenue. Meaning you're optimizing for tire kickers, not customers.

Alternatively, Heatmap takes 2 minutes to install, and lets you track the revenue tied to every element on your site.

These actionable insights make it easy to make the changes you need to increase:

→ Conversion rates.

→  Average order value.

Don’t just take our word for it.

Essential Essence installed Heatmap back in 2023. Using Heatmap, Revenue Per Session shot up by 24%, resulting in $600,000 in additional revenue.

Think your brand would benefit from higher conversion rates?

  • Savvy SaaS Businesses: Brands like Heymarket are using this platform to get more signups and demos from organic search traffic. (LINK)

  • Short-form retention: Million-dollar short-form video tip to make retention rate go above 100%. (LINK)

  • Wild campaigns: Japanese marketing campaigns are wild. (LINK)

  • Personal brand: How to turn a personal brand into a company. (LINK)

  • Step by Step: Here's how you can execute a successful founder-led content program in 2024. (LINK)

Current Favorite Tools

  • Always use Ignite Digital when growing traffic for a service business. (LINK) 

  • A massive database of UGC creators (LINK)

Got questions about ideation? Hit me back and I’ll help with whatever.

Alex G

More Marketing Examined

  • Your playbook to disrupt bigger brands. (LINK)

  • The best creative brainstorm on the internet. (LINK)

  • Learn how to go viral on Instagram within 30 days. (LINK)